Community Assembly

Community Assembly | 2026-10-02
Source: City of Spokane, Assembled PlanSpokane Comments (October 2 packet).
Packet record C021-P635 | PDF pages 141, 142, 143, 144, 145, 146, 147, 148, 149, 150, 151, 152, 153, 154, 155, 156, 157, 158, 159, 160, 161, 162, 163, 164, 165, 166, 167, 168, 169, 170, 171, 172, 173, 174, 175.
Reviewed reading copy. Personal contact details are omitted.

Subject as filed: Comments on Comprehensive Plan Update from Community Assembly

[Source PDF page 141]

image.png
Community Assembly of the Neighborhoods of The City of Spokane
RE: Letters from Community Assembly
At the September Community Assembly meeting the letter attached entitled CA Letter - Sept.pdf was approved by a vote of the body to be submitted to the Mayor, City Council and Planning Department. This letter requested a 6 month extension to the Comprehensive Plan update feedback deadline. At that meeting we were informed that an extension would not be possible, but regardless the body wanted to communicate the specific concerns listed therein.
At the October CA Meeting, yesterday, two additional letters detailing feedback from the Neighborhood Councils on the specific language of the Comprehensive Plan update drafts. The first, CA Letter Ch3.pdf was approved for submission as feedback from the neighborhoods.
The second, CA Letter August Draft, was created by a subcommittee of the CA Land Use Committee and approved by that committee and submitted to the CA for approval. The Community Assembly voted to refer this Comprehensive Plan update feedback to all of you as the work of the CA Land Use Committee. Full adoption of this language by all neighborhoods was not possible due to the short timeline between when the draft was made available, when the Land Use Committee meets and when the Community Assembly meets.
An additional letter was also approved on the topic of development It is entitled CA

[Source PDF page 142]

Letter Safeguarding Neighborhood Livability.pdf. This letter includes specific requests addressed to the City Council.
My apologies for all this bulk in one email. Cancelling our meeting in August due to the fires and other timing challenges led to all of this coming together just last night.
On behalf of all the neighborhoods of The City of Spokane
Luke Tolley
Administrative Committee Chair
In Community
Luke Tolley
he/his
phone:
Hillyard, Spokane, Washington

[Personal contact details omitted from the reading text.]

[Source PDF page 143]

RE: Resolution
Whereas in August Spokane suffered one of the most destructive and expensive fires in Washington history, with over 800 homes destroyed, some 65,000 people displaced, over 7,700 acres burned, and over $1 billion in estimated damages, and
Whereas Spokane faces a very long road to recovery from a fire of this magnitude, and
Whereas Spokane is predicted to suffer additional wildfires in the coming years, and
Whereas whenever and wherever such large disasters have occurred, projected population growth has been affected
Therefore be it resolved that the city seek an extension of a minimum of six months’ duration to allow the city to react thoughtfully to its changed circumstances by conducting activities including:
• identification and employment of an appropriate expert or experts on effects of
major disasters on population and building, followed by a review and revision of the
city’s expected population growth, based on population expert’s expertise
• evaluation of the appropriateness of the current draft Comprehensive Plan to the
city’s changed circumstances, including a possible revision of the total need for
high density given new population estimates
• thoughtful conversations between the planning department and all neighborhood
councils regarding the neighborhood FLUMs including a reassessment of proposed
high-density zones (including resiliency) in and around neighborhood parks, natural
features (e.g., the river gorge), green spaces and WUIs
• greater measures in the draft plan to adapt to climate change and its effects and to
reduce them, and
• the adaptation of BuildSpokane’s development code to Spokane’s new reality.
Thank you.

[Source PDF page 144]

Re: Draft Chapter 3
What follows are observations and concerns regarding the current draft of Chapter 3:
Growth Strategy. These observations from the Land Use Committee were reviewed and approved to be sent to you for your serious consideration.
General observations
1. Chapter title: We request that the chapter’s title return to its former name: Land Use. The proposed title is misguided. There are a variety of uses for the land in the city. The chapter title “Growth Strategy” gives one to believe the only use of land is to accommodate population growth. Yet the draft chapter itself spells out 9 categories of use, including open spaces. The introduction to the draft chapter identifies designations to meet growth (estimated ca. 23,000 in 20 years), while “capturing other considerations for how land is used and served within city limits.” All uses should be reflected in the chapter title because all uses are essential to a livable city.
2. Demographics: This draft chapter, as well as others, does not consider the changes in the population beyond the numbers. What are the projected ages of the population in the next 20 years? What rapid technology changes will occur that will affect the population and how people live? How will these changes impact the population’s recreational uses, purchasing patterns, preferred living situations, etc.?
3. Neighborhood Councils: The Neighborhood Councils are key to city planning, yet they are barely mentioned throughout the entire draft. The Councils are an explicit part of the planning process as specified by Charter and need to be mentioned in land use planning. A couple of lines in the Governance chapter is insufficient.
4. Tribes: There is almost no mention of the Tribes, yet the City is located on unceded lands of the tribes. Where are the Tribes in planning for land use?
5. Vision: The words “future vision” are used, but the document fails to specify whose vision. Again, the neighborhood councils must be integral participants in creating the vision.
6. Density: Two land uses are Residential High Density and Residential Low Density.
However, when reviewing the definition of these two uses, 10-15 units per acre are

[Source PDF page 145]

not covered by either density. The chapter needs to introduce a 10th use: Medium Density.
7. Home Ownership: This draft chapter, by allowing for higher density throughout the city, will negatively affect home ownership. Already home ownership numbers are on the decline and the average age of people purchasing homes is increasing. This chapter’s plan will reduce the number of ownable dwellings and move more people to rentals, which will negatively affect equity accumulation, new family formation, generational wealth, and thus the city’s and the region’s economy.
Specific observations
The following comments are based on a comparison of the Land Use chapter of the 2017 Comprehensive Plan update and the May 2026 draft of the current Comprehensive Plan.
p. 2, par. 1 Sentence in 2017 about the development of neighborhood plans omitted.
p. 2, par. 1 details about earlier plans and updates omitted
p. 2, par. 2 definition of land use omitted
p. 2, par. 3 role of citizen volunteers omitted; detailed ‘Values’ section with emphasis on natural areas and neighborhoods omitted
p. 2 “Capacity to Accommodate Growth” This section in the 2017 Update began with “Neighborhoods”; they are omitted here and relegated to p. 24 with a reduced text. The section emphasizing the importance of downtown is moved to p. 4. The actual Land Use section starts on p. 21.
pp. 3-4 Rather than 2017’s organization by type of neighborhood, this section in 2026 organizes by type of development. It is only made clear on p. 19 that all of these types of development are mixed use and that therefore mixed use will occur in all neighborhoods.
p. 7 final paragraph Given the paragraph’s initial emphasis on the evolution toward transit, the reference to the current “auto-oriented” use of corridors should be completed at the end of the paragraph by reference to the future use of transit and active transportation.
Open space. Predominant Uses.
p. 9-10 Given that the “Open Spaces” designation includes sports complexes, the recommendation that “Open Space Designations should prioritize parks or outdoor recreational facilities and opportunities, especially where views and proximity to nature provide essential benefits to the community, such as the Spokane River Gorge” could be seen as encouraging the building of a stadium atop the Spokane River Gorge and other such projects, degrading the genuine “open spaces” much valued by Spokanites.
The second paragraph describes the inclusion in this category of lands “warranting protection from encroachment” for their value in a variety of categories. How will the distinction between lands to be protected from encroachment and lands to “provide opportunities for active and passive recreation” be made? Who will make it? Why are these two very different types of land use lumped together in one category?
Residential Low

[Source PDF page 146]

p. 11-12 Secondary Uses “Allowances ... neighborhood.” Who will decide when a “larger development” will provide a “benefit to the local neighborhood” and therefore be allowed in a “Residential Low” designation? A statement that the neighborhood council will have an advisory role in this decision must be added to this text.
p. 12 Intensity Who will decide when greater intensity is “acceptable”? A statement that the neighborhood council will have a role in this decision must be added to this text.
Residential High
p. 12 What are the dimensional criteria for “larger multi-unit developments” and “more intense middle-housing types?
p. 13 Location criteria How can new Residential High areas be created without displacing current residents?
Institutional
p. 14 second sentence from top “residential density in industrial areas”--shouldn’t this be “residential density in institutional areas”?
Mixed Use
p. 15 Secondary Uses It is unclear how active transportation would work safely in a mixed- use zone.
p. 16 Location Criteria With this being the basic designation for Urban Hubs, this kind of anything-goes zone will appear all over the city.
Goals and Policies
p. 18 Goal GS-1, Uses of Land The corresponding Goals and Policies section of the 2017 update was located at the beginning of the document. Its first point (LU 1.1, pp. 8-9) setting forth neighborhoods as the basic feature of Land Use has been excised. LU 1.3 (p. 9) opens the ‘Discussion’ portion: “The city’s residential neighborhoods are one of its most valuable assets.” That statement and the paragraph that develops it have been excised.
p. 19 GS-1.4, Industry & Employment This section makes no reference to professional sectors that are important to the local economy: health care and post-secondary education.
p. 19 GS-1.6 Urban Agriculture 2017’s reference to determination of this land in consultation with Natural Resource Conservation Service and expectation that it remain agricultural for at least 20 years omitted.
p. 19 GS-1.7 Parks & Open Spaces The subsuming of the freestanding Open Spaces Policy
(LU 6.2) to the Parks Policy caused the loss of: “Conservation Open Space includes areas that are publicly owned, not developed, and designated to remain in a natural state. It is intended to protect areas with high scenic value, environmentally sensitive conditions, historic or cultural values, priority animal habitats, and/or passive recreational features. It is expected that improvements in these areas would be limited to those supporting preservation or some passive recreation activities, like soft trails and wildlife viewpoints.”
p. 20 GS-2.7 Sub-Area Planning Framework To the existing initial phrase in bold should be added: “Undertake sub-area and neighborhood planning in collaboration with neighborhood councils, local residents and impacted community members...”
p. 21 GS-2.11 Neighborhoods The displacement of the consideration of neighborhoods to near the end of the document and the omission of the discussion are a real loss relative to 2017’s emphasis on Spokane as a place where people live.

[Source PDF page 147]

p. 21 GS-3.1 Addressing Housing Displacement This section should add a consideration of the reduction in home ownership when homes are demolished and replaced by rental property.
p. 23 GS-6.1 Transit Oriented Development 2017’s considerations of reducing through traffic and block length (LU 4.3, 4.5, p. 27) have been excised.
p. 26 GS-8.4 Siting Essential Public Facilities The omission of 2017’s examples of the types of facilities involved makes this section vague.
p. 27 GS-10.1 Annexation Boundaries The omission of the “Discussion” section of the corresponding section of 2017 (LU 9.1, pp. 36-37) results in the loss of “preservation of natural neighborhoods and communities” as a criterion for decision-making.
p. 27 GS-10.4, Land Use and Zoning Designations upon Annexation The phrase in 2017’s corresponding section (LU 9.6, p. 38), “Recognize the interests of the residents of the annexing area” has been excised.
p. 27 2017’s 9.4 Community Impacts (p. 37) has been excised. pp. 28-29 Policies Removed from the Text.
The following removed policies should be reinstated in the 2026 Comprehensive Plan:
Policy: LU-2.1, Public Realm Features Encourage features that improve the appearance of development, paying attention to how projects function to encourage social interaction and relate to and enhance the surrounding urban and natural environment.
Policy: LU-2.2, Performance Standards
Employ performance and design standards with sufficient flexibility and appropriate incentives to ensure that development is compatible with surrounding land uses.
Policy: LU-4.3, Neighborhood Through-Traffic
Create boundaries for new neighborhoods through which principal arterials should not pass.
Policy: LU-4.5, Block Length
Create a network of streets that is generally laid out in a grid pattern that features more street intersections and shorter block lengths in order to increase street connectivity and access.
Goal: LU-5, Development Character
Promote development in a manner that is attractive, complementary, and compatible with other land uses.
Policy: LU-5.4, Natural Features and Habitat Protection
Ensure development is accomplished in a manner that protects significant natural features and wildlife habitat.

[Source PDF page 148]

Comments on the August 2026 draft of the 2046 Comprehensive Plan
Executive Summary
The principal aim of the Comprehensive Plan, as stated in its introduction (p. 2), is to “[i]dentify locations where different types of growth should occur, guiding both private and public development.”
Features
• making all resources available to all residents of all income levels everywhere in the city
• inclusion of all of the city’s residents and demographic groups, beginning with a detailed land acknowledgment
• increased housing density especially near transit
• numerous new climate-related goals and policies
Partial Improvements, more needed
• housing density added but more of it should meet the greatest need, in lower income bands (see Draft Environmental Impact Statement, p. 85 Exhibit 2.2-2.
Housing Target and Affordable Housing Capacity 2020-2046 that shows 4,400- unit shortage at 0-80% of Area Median Income [AMI] but 6,000-unit excess at 80-120% AMI and 9,000-unit excess at 120%+ AMI)
• the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and vehicle miles traveled as a means of reducing climate hazards is now included in the Introduction (p. 7); however, the Draft Environmental Impact Statement (p. 390) predicts that Alternative 2, now the Preferred Alternative, will produce no decline in use of single-occupant vehicles, no increase in the use of transit, and a bare .02% increase in active transportation
• Emergency Management section with numerous policies added to Chapter 10
need for specific funded projects (e.g. more connectivity in North Indian Trail area)
• Neighborhood Councils included in specific policies per Community Assembly recommendation. Their advisory role should be added to Chapter 3, pp. 11-12 Secondary Uses and Intensity in Residential Low areas; p. 22 GS-5.1 Designate and Plan Urban Hubs; p. 26 GS-8.4 Siting Essential Public Facilities; Chapter 12
Parks and Recreation, p. 8 restore PR-7.7 Public Participation. The role of neighborhoods should be restored to many Goals and Policies: e.g. in Chapter 11 Neighborhoods, planning that begins in the neighborhood and in Chapter 8 Urban Design and Historic Preservation, DP 5 Local Determination. Neighborhoods
should be recognized as communities within the community
• some measures supportive of the arts have been added in Chapter 10; restore those, such as funding directives for developers, that have been removed
• greater attention to the natural environment; correct policies such as the subsuming of Conservation Open Space into Open Space, access to the river from commercial venues, inclusion of built recreational venues such as stadiums as
1

[Source PDF page 149]

‘open space’ (Chapter 3 pp. 9-10), and the conversion of 2017’s ED 8 Quality of Life and the Environment to 2026’s EP-9 Tourism Promotion, which have the potential to result in damage to the environment.
• Convert the compendium of climate-related material to a chapter
Needed improvements
• restore name and orientation of “Land Use” to Chapter 3
• restore name “Implementation” to Chapter 2 (now Community Indicators) and the detailed matrices tracking City work projects
• respect the integrity of registered historic districts and restore ‘Neighborhoods’ to DP-2.16 Historic Districts (the equivalent of 2017’s DP 3.13 Historic Districts and Neighborhoods)
• recognize the importance to civic and economic life of education at all levels and of the contributions of higher education to the economy through research and teaching in areas such as health care, engineering, agriculture, and public policy and through attracting thousands of students.
• return Chapter 9 Natural Environment NE-1.5 Mining Activities and 1.8 Toxic
Dumping Regulations to their earlier wording
• sidebars: finalize cross-references to relocated goals and policies and information about deleted ones
• Future Land Use Map: reduce the increased density proposed for fire-prone areas along the Spokane River gorge and evacuation routes from them to reduce exposure to future wildfires and direct more density to the underutilized lots closer to the center of the city and to transit.
2

[Source PDF page 150]

Comments to Specific Chapters
The page numbers refer to the counter in the upper left corner of the pdf.
Chapter 1 Introduction
p. 1 “Each has been discussed at the Plan Commission, by various Plan Commission subcommittees, with City Council in general, and shared with the public at various points along the way.”
The role of the Planning Department has not been stated here.
p. 2 Most of the items on the bulletted list of what the Comp Plan will achieve are new and vague (e.g. “Create a collective vision for the City of Spokane’s future,” “public investment,” “future plans, programs, and initiatives”) where 2017 specified services to be provided to residents: “Transportation, public improvements, and public services that are desired” and “Actions to protect the natural environment.”
p. 2 2017’s paragraph describing the provisions in the Growth Management Act to ensure that the City follows the Comprehensive Plan has been deleted. pp. 3-5 Welcome additions include the history of the Spokane indigenous people, of Chinese and Japanese communities, and of the Black community; and the land acknowledgment. Unwelcome, however, are the reduction of information about the aquifer and the deletion of information about Spokanites putting parks and the preservation of nature at the center of the city’s identity. While discussion of Spokane's air pollution problem and the significant contribution that automobiles make to it has been added on p. 7, 2017’s placement of it at the beginning acknowledged its centrality.
While the addition of detail about local events enriches the account, the deletion of much of the information (2017 pp. 5-8) about population fluctuation over the years and of the region’s geology and climate impoverishes it. The declaration (p. 4) that early “unique housing choices that are still treasured to this day” conflicts with the number of them that the City is allowing to be demolished and the lack of consideration of registered historic districts in drawing up the Future Land Use Map. pp. 5-6 The section entitled “Implementing the Community’s Vision” deals in vague terms: “After a robust visioning process, the community developed a vision statement.” By contrast, 2017 (p. 11): “the City of Spokane’s citizen participation process . . . involved all segments of the community in shaping the city’s future.” A list of ways stimulating “broad citizen involvement” would “build affective relationships among government, the community and neighborhoods, business and their constituents to empower citizens and provide a broader perspective on Spokane’s future” and allow the City “To understand the public’s expectations for growth management planning, including the content and products of the process.” The extensive list of constituted groups with which the City worked in developing the 2017 Comprehensive Plan (pp. 13- 15 and Appendix I) finds no correspondence in this chapter, which terms such engagement “transactional” (p. 11).
p. 6 The May version’s “guiding principles that community members identified as important as we plan for the next 20 years” has become “guiding principles . . . that reflect community priorities.”
pp. 6-7 “Plan for Housing” is the first item on the list of “Guiding Principles,” followed by “Plan for Equity,” “Plan for Climate Resiliency,” “Plan for Community Well-Being,”
3

[Source PDF page 151]

and “Plan for Economic Prosperity.”
p. 7 The addition of means for achieving community connection is welcome.
p. 7 The addition of the reduction of vehicle miles traveled and greenhouse gas emissions as means of reducing climate hazards is welcome.
p. 7 The “Plan for Economic Prosperity” makes no mention of the role of higher education or the presence of local institutions of higher education in promoting and achieving prosperity and the flexibility required to sustain it in evolving conditions. On p. 5 they are depicted as merely benefiting from local industry whereas in reality higher education is an economic engine for the city that draws thousands of students and conducts teaching and research that benefit local economic sectors including health care, engineering, agriculture, and public policy.
pp. 7-8 This is a much shorter version of the account of the GMA and its relevance and of countywide planning that in 2017 occupied pp. 9-11. For example, 2017’s “Manage Shorelines Wisely” becomes “Shoreline management.” Why was ‘wisely’ excised?
p. 9 The section on the regional planning including allocation of population projection is new.
p. 9 The “Who Plans and How” section contains no reference to the Planning Department, and repeats the 2017 wording that the Comprehensive Plan is “prepared by involved citizens.” Yet while 2017’s process had systematic work with community bodies in addition to outreach sessions to the larger public, most of the outreach efforts of the Planning Department have been sporadic public input sessions that provided “touchpoints.” Summaries of the outreach sessions prepared by “Our teams” are available in Appendix 1 Public Participation and Engagement, but complete, primary-source documentation has yet to be made publicly available. Oral interactions that were not recorded or written down by the participant are not (completely) memorialized.
p. 10 May’s “citizens’ interests” has become “local interests.”
p. 10 The only reference to the Planning Department is in a statement that it evaluated language access and provided opportunities for translation and interpretation, which is outside the Planning Department’s area of professional expertise.
p. 11 The secondary-source summaries of public feedback prepared by the Planning Department are publicly available, but primary-source direct documentation is not yet available.
p. 11 While the ‘open house’ style meetings of the present process described here reached a larger number of residents, the “continuous citizen participation” required by the GMA (p. 10) was more clearly met in the creation of the 2017 Comprehensive Plan and in the current Re-Five Project, both of which also involved regular meetings with specific bodies over the course of the work. The oral reactions of members of the public attending ‘open house’ meetings were not recorded unless the individual wrote them down on a comment card.
Chapter 2 Community Indicators [formerly Implementation]
Because Community Indicators was published for the first time in May, the comparisons here are solely to the corresponding chapter of the 2017 Comprehensive Plan. 2017’s 86- page Implementation provided matrices of near- and mid-term projects and ongoing projects in an easily readable grid giving the goal, policy number, description of policy, related elements, future projects, and timeframe for completion. Complete matrices were
4

[Source PDF page 152]

made available in the 101-page Appendix G Work Plan Matrices Future Matrix and Master Matrix.
2026 uses a different system. Its 10-page Community Indicators uses a narrative text that describes two kinds of monitoring, setting out the major issues to be tracked and the outcome and process indicators to be used. The first kind of monitoring is what is required for the state’s mandatory 5-year check-in, which includes issues such as Housing by Income Band, Permit Processing Timelines, Greenhouse Gas Emissions, etc.
The second is Continued Monitoring, which involves larger issues: Population Growth and Demographics, Land Use and Growth Strategy, Equity and Belonging, Community
Resiliency, Community Well-being, Economic Prosperity, and Tribal and Urban Native
Collaboration and Coordination. It concludes with a feature induced by public feedback, an Accountability Framework. However, that framework includes no timeline or form for how such actions as “Information on progress will be made accessible to the public.” Some of the matrix information is placed in Appendix 2 Capital Facilities Plan, which contains some future plans but lacks a timeline grid. A side bar explains that, “Details such as the previous matrices are working documents and best left out of the Comprehensive Plan for useability and adaptability.” However, as the 2017 text states, “Information and progress on Plan implementation is documented and disseminated through bi-annual reports to the community (matrix update) . . . . This chapter of the Plan should be viewed as an action plan and should be updated as progress occurs on these items.” The matrices and specific terms of the Accountability Framework therefore should be restored to fulfill this chapter’s title.
p. 3 The list of city-regulated matters is considerably reduced.
p. 3 A vague reference to “the community’s vision” supersedes 2017’s crediting of the contribution of many civic groups and institutions to “this shared responsibility for community action.”
Chapter 3 Growth Strategy [formerly Land Use]
Evident in the new name, this chapter’s new orientation sidelines all uses of land but growth. While the explanatory sidebar (p. 2) refers to planning under the Growth Management Act, that act had already guided the 2017 update.
p. 2, par. 1 Sentence in 2017 about the development of neighborhood plans omitted.
p. 2, par. 1 2017’s details about earlier plans and updates omitted
p. 2, par. 2 2017’s definition of land use omitted
p. 2, par. 3 2017’s role of citizen volunteers omitted; detailed ‘Values’ section with emphasis on natural areas and neighborhoods omitted
p. 2 “Capacity to Accommodate Growth” The placing of this new section first, rather than 2017’s “Neighborhoods” (which is relegated to p. 24 with a reduced text), risks features that make Spokane a desirable place to live. People live and form communities in neighborhoods. The section emphasizing the importance of downtown is moved to p.
4. The actual Land Use section starts on p. 21. An assessment of the “much more detailed data on capacity and growth” that a sidebar states “will be included in a technical appendix” will only be possible when that appendix has been made public.
In addition, the rationale that this section gives for the chapter’s proposals:
Overall, the City has sufficient capacity to accommodate the expected population growth through 2046. The Comprehensive Plan has been crafted towards
5

[Source PDF page 153]

accommodating that growth and housing affordability for all income brackets, ensuring consistency with the community’s vision for the future. suffers from two important problems:
• it does little to meet the extensive need for the most affordable housing (according to the Draft Environmental Impact Study, p. 308: 6,452 units of non- Permanent Supportive Housing for those at 0-30% of Area Median Income; 1,851 units of Permanent Supportive Housing for those at 0-30% of Area Median Income; 4,413 units of housing for those at 30-50% of Area Median Income; 2,631 units of housing for those at 50-80% of Area Median Income; total: 15,347)
• it has not been re-considered since the Spokane Complex fires destroyed significant portions of the city.
Nor does the chapter mention that while the housing need could be satisfied with a 1% increase of land for intensified housing, the plan takes 16% (City presentation, April 14, 2026, p. 48), increasing the potential for disruption to existing livable neighborhoods. pp. 3-4 Rather than 2017’s organization by type of neighborhood, this section in 2026 organizes by type of development. It is not stated until p. 19 that all development types are mixed use, which means that mixed use will occur in all neighborhoods.
p. 5 What source/s will fund the many amenities characterizing Urban Hubs?
Open space. Predominant Uses.
p. 9-10 The 2017 update LU-6.2 divided Conservation Open Space from Open Space
2026 puts both, without distinction, into the category “Open Space,” with the second paragraph noting that this category includes lands “warranting protection from encroachment.” But it does not identify them and lacks measures and a process for doing so. Given that Open Space also includes sports complexes, the recommendation that “Open Space Designations should prioritize parks or outdoor recreational facilities and opportunities, especially where views and proximity to nature provide essential benefits to the community, such as the Spokane River Gorge” could be seen as encouraging the building of a stadium with parking lot atop the Spokane River Gorge and other such projects, degrading the genuine “open spaces” much valued by Spokanites.
Residential Low
In the 2026 Spokane Development Code Assessment (p. 59), the category “Residential Low” combines 2017’s “Residential Low” (R1) and “Residential Plus” (R2, which permitted slightly greater density in a transitional area to Centers and Corridors and commercial areas). 2017’s “Residential Low” allowed from 4 to 10 dwelling units per acre (dua), which the August draft continues to state as the upper limit (p. 12). However, the 2026 Development Code Assessment allows up to 20, which would force neighborhood density zones to accommodate as much as five times their current density.
p. 11-12 Secondary Uses “Allowances for larger development . . . if they provide residential capacity or other benefit to the local neighborhood.” Who will decide when a “larger development” will provide a “benefit to the local neighborhood” and therefore be allowed in a “Residential Low” designation? A statement that the neighborhood council will have an advisory role in this decision must be added to this text.
p. 12 Intensity “Greater intensity is more acceptable” in several situations. A statement that the neighborhood council will have an advisory role in this decision must be added to this text.
Residential High
6

[Source PDF page 154]

The current draft says that this category allows between 15 and 40 dua, leaving a gap between its lower limit and the “Residential Low” upper limit of 10 dua. The 2026 Spokane Development Code Assessment allows “Residential Low” an upper limit of 20 dua and gives no limits for Residential High. The key to this mystery perhaps is found in the number of units allowed in the Mixed Use category, 10 to 45, which may also reveal how widely the Mixed Use category is intended to be used throughout the city (see also
p. 22).
p. 12 What are the dimensional criteria for “larger multi-unit developments” and “more intense middle-housing types?
p. 13 Location criteria How can new Residential High areas be created without displacing current residents?
Commercial
p. 14 Predominant Uses It is unclear how active transportation would work safely in a commercial zone.
Mixed Use
p. 15 Secondary Uses It is unclear how active transportation would work safely in a mixed-use zone.
p. 16 Location Criteria With this being the basic designation for Urban Hubs, this kind of zone will appear all over the city.
Downtown
p. 17 Location Criteria “Designating areas of predominantly single-unit or middle housing should include consideration for potential displacement of existing residents.” This sentence assumes that new single-unit or middle housing would be developed where multi-unit, low-cost housing currently exists. Where exactly would that be?
Goals and Policies
p. 18 Goal GS-1, Uses of Land The corresponding Goals and Policies section of the 2017 update was located at the beginning of the document. Its first point (LU 1.1, pp. 8-
9) setting forth neighborhoods as the basic feature of Land Use has been excised. LU 1.3 (p. 9) opens the ‘Discussion’ portion: “The city’s residential neighborhoods are one of its most valuable assets.” That statement and the paragraph that develops it have been excised.
p. 19 GS-1.4 Industry and Employment The addition of medical and educational uses here is welcome.
p. 19 GS-1.6 Urban Agriculture While the addition of small-scale urban agriculture to this section is welcome, the deletion of much of 2017’s lengthy discussion is not. That discussion included the determination of long-term agricultural land in consultation with Natural Resource Conservation Service and the expectation that it remain agricultural for at least 20 years. It also specified that uses of adjacent land should be compatible by limiting density, including buffer zones, and various other specified means.
p. 19 GS-1.7 Parks & Open Spaces The subsuming of the freestanding Open Spaces Policy (LU 6.2) to the Parks Policy caused the loss of the following affirmation:
“Conservation Open Space includes areas that are publicly owned, not developed, and designated to remain in a natural state. It is intended to protect areas with high scenic value, environmentally sensitive conditions, historic or cultural values, priority animal habitats, and/or passive recreational features. It is expected that improvements in these
7

[Source PDF page 155]

areas would be limited to those supporting preservation or some passive recreation activities, like soft trails and wildlife viewpoints.”
p. 20 GS-2.3 Displacement Risk This is a welcome new policy.
p. 20 GS-2.4 Non-Conforming Uses The sidebar statement (LU 2.4 Expanded to reflect existing policies allowing for grandfathered uses.) is quite confusing. There is no LU 2.4
the similar policy in 2017 is LU 1.14 and its orientation is to limit the amount of non- conforming uses. GS-2.4, instead, is likely to increase them to avoid displacing earlier residents when new development of a different type occurs.
p. 20 GS-2.6 Lot Sizes The addition of home ownership and density of non-residential building is welcome.
p. 20 GS-2.7 Sub-Area Planning Framework The addition of ‘Neighborhood Councils’
as collaborating bodies is welcome.
p. 20 GS-2.8 Built and Natural Environment The addition of wildfire risk to considerations is welcome.
p. 21 GS-2.9 Encouraging Infill Development, GS-2.10 Land Use Transitions, GS-
2.12 Connection and Accessibility These are welcome new policies.
p. 21 GS-2.11 Neighborhoods The displacement of the neighborhoods section to near the end of the document and the omission of the discussion are a real loss relative to 2017’s emphasis on Spokane’s neighborhoods as where people live.
p. 21 GS-3.1 Addressing Housing Displacement This section should add a consideration of the reduction in home ownership when homes are demolished and replaced by rental property. The DEIS (p. 285) anticipates the demolition of approximately 1,200 single-unit dwellings under the Preferred Alternative.
p. 21 GS-3.2 Access to Transportation The inclusion of VMT and emissions here is welcome.
pp. 21-22 GS-3.3 Reducing Sprawl; GS-3.4 Infrastructure Investment These are
welcome new policies.
p. 22 GS-4 Mix of Uses This new goal and related policies will have a range of consequences, which will likely be perceived variously by Spokane communities and residents.
pp. 22-23 GS-5.1 Urban Hubs This new goal and related policies will have a range of consequences, which will likely be perceived variously by Spokane communities and residents.
p. 22 GS-5.1 Designate and Plan Urban Hubs
The list of those consulted in such designation and planning should read “in consultation with relevant City departments and operations and Neighborhood Councils.” p, 23 GS-6 Transit-Oriented Development The new title recognizes the increased emphasis on transit already evident in 2017’s Transportation.
p. 23 GS-6.1 Transit Oriented Development While the emphasis on transit is welcome, the excision of 2017’s considerations of reducing through-traffic and block length (LU 4.3, 4.5, p. 27) is not.
p. 23 GS-6.2 Vehicle Miles Traveled Reduction The emphasis on transit is welcome. pp. 24-25 GS-7 Resilient Land Use This new goal and related policies are welcome, and will be more so as specific, funded projects that implement them are undertaken. Should this section not also include one or more policies specifically about building in fire-prone
8

[Source PDF page 156]

areas? Currently there are references to the Wildland Urban Interface in GS-7.2 and GS- 7.3.
p. 24 GS-7.3 Wildland-Urban Interface Outreach Should this or another policy in this section not include evacuation routes as a consideration?
p. 25 GS-7.8 Food Access This is a welcome new policy.
p. 25 GS-7.9 Tree Canopy This is a welcome new policy, especially in light of the number of trees currently being cut down to make way for dense development.
p. 25 GS-8.2 Coordination and Partnerships with Providers This is a welcome new policy.
p. 26 GS-8.4 Siting Essential Public Facilities The omission of 2017’s examples of the types of facilities involved makes this section vague. The final sentence should read “engaging directly with impacted community members and Neighborhood Councils.”
p. 26 GS-8.6 Surplus City Property The specification of “non-profit organizations for community benefit and neighborhood revitalization” is welcome.
p. 27 GS-10.1 Annexation Boundaries The omission of the “Discussion” of the corresponding section of 2017 (LU 9.1, pp. 36-37) results in the loss of “preservation of natural neighborhoods and communities” as a criterion for decision-making.
p. 27 GS-10.4 Land Use and Zoning Designations upon Annexation The excised
phrase of 2017’s corresponding section (LU 9.6, p. 38), “Recognize the interests of the residents of the annexing area,” should be restored.
p. 28 GS-10.7 Weighing Fiscal Impacts of Annexation This is a welcome new policy. pp. 28-30 Policies Removed from the Text
The sidebars indicating where policies removed from this chapter were intended to be placed in other chapters must be updated to give specific cross-references to where they actually appear or state that they have been definitively removed. pp. 28-30 The following removed policies should be reinstated in this chapter of the 2026 Comprehensive Plan:
Policy: LU-4.3 Neighborhood Through-Traffic
Create boundaries for new neighborhoods through which principal arterials should not pass.
Policy: LU-4.5 Block Length
Create a network of streets that is generally laid out in a grid pattern that features more street intersections and shorter block lengths in order to increase street connectivity and access.
Goal: LU-5 Development Character
Promote development in a manner that is attractive, complementary, and compatible with other land uses.
Policy: LU-5.4 Natural Features and Habitat Protection
Ensure development is accomplished in a manner that protects significant natural features and wildlife habitat.
Policy: LU-7.1 Regulatory Structure
Develop a land use regulatory structure that utilizes a variety of mechanisms to promote development that provides a public benefit.
Chapter 4 Transportation
The broad and deep differences between the 88-page 2017 version and the 33-page
9

[Source PDF page 157]

August 2026 version exclude a line-by-line comparison. Therefore most comments focus on the August 2026 version compared with the May 2026 version. Features of 2017’s “Vision and Values” statement (p. 12) that do not appear in the present version are “Maintaining the ability to access quickly the outdoors from the city”; “Decreasing north- south congestion”; and “Developing convenient access to the downtown area, increasing parking, bus service, light rail, and satellite parking with shuttles, and improving the pedestrian environment.” Goal E Respect Natural & Community Assets was removed and its content largely transferred to policies TR-2.3 Natural Environment and Cultural Heritage and TR-2.4 Natural Environment and “Achieving Context-Sensitive Design.”
The chapter in general shows a laudable shift to active and public transportation, emphasizing its benefits to safety and health and the reduction of climate-warming greenhouse gas emissions. It also adds considerations around the safe operation of personal motor vehicles. These two features are part of a laudable emphasis on community, both the life of the community as a central focus of transportation planning and planners’ seeking the community’s preferences when developing plans.
p. 2 sidebar refers to appendices. When will these appear?
pp. 2-3 the phrase “With forecasted growth” has been deleted.
p. 3 much of the short paragraph giving the reasons for the priorities has been deleted, including “the growth and development of Spokane.”
p. 3 2017’s paragraph (p. 18) listing the government programs that the City will use to improve safety has been deleted. A current list should be included.
p. 4 2017’s human being (p. 15) is omitted from the definition of ‘sense of place’. pp. 5-6 Welcome additions to the chapter’s themes are “Ensuring Sustainable Funding for Operations and Maintenance,” “Achieving Climate Goals,” and “Enhancing Resiliency.”
pp. 6-7 Goal TR-1 Enhance Public Safety and Health The new prominence of this goal and the addition to it and related policies of the safe operation of vehicles and of evacuation needs are welcome developments.
p. 8 TR-2.2 Effective Community Engagement: Neighborhood Councils have been
added to the community partners that provide input.
p. 9 TR-3.2 Upgrade Network to Meet Standards, TR-3.3 Base Standards on the
Intended Users, and TR-3.4 Limit Exceptions to Street Standards are welcome new policies addressing improvements to standards.
p. 13 TR-8 Ensure Sustainable Funding for Operations and Maintenance is a welcome new policy.
p. 14 TR-9 Achieve Climate Goals This new goal and its policies are a welcome development. Clarification is needed to relate their “targeted reductions in Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT) and associated reductions in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions” to the Draft EIS’s total combined increase of only .03% in active transportation and none in public transit. Are this new goal and its policies envisioned as resulting in a greater increase?
pp. 15-16 TR-10 Enhancing Resiliency in the Transportation Network This is a welcome new goal addressing climate considerations.
p. 16 TR-11 Achieve Context Sensitive Design This is a welcome new goal.
p. 16 TR-11.3 Infrastructure Design The following acronyms should be spelled out:
MUTCD, NAACTO, AASHTO
p. 17 (and p. 8 for TR 2.3, TR 2.4) sidebar says that former TR Goal E
10

[Source PDF page 158]

Respect Natural and Community Assets
Protect natural, community, and neighborhood assets to create and connect places where people live their daily lives in a safe and healthy environment. has been removed and concepts added to TR 2.3 and TR 2.4. While those two policies add welcome detail, TR 2.3 should have restored to it the 2017 verb “to create” and should define the “objective criteria” that will be used to “[e]valuate the impact of transportation projects on natural and community assets.”
Chapter 5 Capital Facilities
The review of this chapter requires specific expertise.
Chapter 6 Housing
Current emphasis is on expanding all types of housing everywhere. While H-4.1 makes optional 2017’s H-1.8 requirement of “a percentage of affordable housing within all new developments,” it adds incentives. While “increasing home ownership” was removed from the list of priorities, policy H-2.3 was added in response to “the community’s desire for more home ownership opportunities” and H-4.5 has added “residents” and “owner- occupied housing” to partnerships. Welcome changes include the grouping in policy H- 1.5 of various and new funding mechanisms to incentivize building and home ownership
the encouraging of infill and of lower-barrier housing options in H-2; and the addition of H-6.3 on energy efficiency and H-7.3 on climate coping mechanisms.
p. 2 Housing Strategy
Will the anticipated “population growth of 23,357 between 2020 and 2046” be reviewed with experts on the effect of major disasters on cities? For example, fifteen years after Katrina, New Orleans had 100,000 fewer residents (a 20% loss).
A sentence should be added between the first and second sentences of this paragraph giving statistics about the current housing shortage. pp. 3-4 2017’s increasing home ownership is not among the 2026 chapter’s priorities. pp. 4-5 H-1 Planning for Housing The expansions of policies in this goal are generally welcome.
p. 4 H-1.1 Accommodating Spokane’s Housing Needs This is a welcome new policy.
p. 5 H-1.3 Regional Fair Share Housing, H-1.7, Housing Goal Monitoring
“Participate in a process that monitors and adjusts the distribution of lower-income housing throughout the region, promoting equitable distribution and access to housing everywhere.”
What will this process consist of?
p. 5 H-1.4 Use of Existing Infrastructure
Welcome encouragement of infill where infrastructure and services already exist.
p. 5 H-1.5 Expanded Opportunity for Incentives and Funding
The added features of this policy (“Expand opportunities for housing development and homeownership, including exploration of new funding mechanisms, property and sales tax reform, and incentives”) offer welcome new possibilities.
p. 5 H-1.7 Housing Goal Monitoring The expansion of this goal is welcome.
p. 6 H-2.2 Creative Housing Options The encouragement of a variety of lower-barrier options is welcome.
11

[Source PDF page 159]

p. 6 H-2.6 Accessory Dwelling Units “Promote the development” of ADUs “that can be sold individually” How will the ownership of the land as well as the dwelling be handled? Will this result in situations such as in mobile home parks, where the owner of the land can charge rent from the owner of the ADU? What happens if the owner sells the land?
p. 7 H-2.10 Cultural and Multigenerational Housing This is a welcome new policy.
p. 7 H-2.12, Preservation, Rehabilitation, Reuse, and Conversion
Is connecting residents with outside governmental funding the only way to encourage preservation and rehabilitation? What about zoning and tax incentives, as the chapter recommends to encourage other forms of housing (e.g. H-1.1, H-1.4, H-1.5, H-2.6, H-3.2
H-4.1)?
p. 7 H-3.1 Aging in Place
How does the call for single-level housing here fit with the overall call for increased density?
pp. 8-9 H-4 Affordable Housing This new goal and many policy expansions are welcome.
p. 8 H-4.5 Partnerships to Reduce Financial Barriers
The addition of “residents” and “owner-occupied housing” is welcome.
p. 9 H-4.6 City Owned Property
“Partner with local housing providers, developers, and other applicable organizations and agencies to identify City owned property that may be appropriate for new development that provides housing units, and update policy and regulations to allow for the transfer or use of those properties.”
Will this policy allow publicly-owned property to be “transferred” to private, for-profit entities or individuals? GS-8.6 Surplus City Property specifies “non-profit organizations for community benefit and neighborhood revitalization.”.
p. 9 H-4.8 Short-Term Rentals This policy’s subordination of short-term housing to residents’ long-term housing needs is welcome.
p. 9 H-4.9 Consistent Supportive Housing Options This new policy is welcome. pp. 9-10 H-5 Housing Equity and Opportunity
This new goal is welcome. How will the Growth Strategy chapter's emphasis on Urban Hubs and multi-family (generally rental) housing affect the achieving of this goal?
p. 10 H-6 Energy Efficiency Assistance This new policy is welcome.
p. 11 H-7 Displacement This new goal and its policies are welcome.
Chapter 7 Economic Prosperity
The addition at various points in the chapter of the community, under-served groups, and cultural value relative to the 2017 plan is welcome. However, the general removal or downgrading of the emphasis on quality of life, the natural environment, and education is concerning.
p. 2 Is the removal from the Introduction of the roles of the downtown and of various industries in Spokane’s economic life a wise change? Similarly, is there wisdom in removing the contents of the Vision Statement
Spokane will enjoy a quality of life for everyone that includes a diversified economic base that provides a livable wage, a healthy natural environment, and an economically vibrant downtown. Spokane’s quality of life will be built on a
12

[Source PDF page 160]

partnership of diverse interests, including education, business, government, and neighborhoods.
and the Values statement
Encouraging economic development that values the environment as a component of our quality of life.
p. 2 EP-1.2 Economic Development Progress The addition of “multi-ethnic, minority, and women-owned businesses” is welcome.
p. 3 EP-1.3 Public-Private Partnerships The addition of education and affordable housing is welcome.
p. 3 EP-2 Development and Redevelopment of Land and Structures Ensure the supply of industrial and commercial properties is sufficient to meet the future economic needs of the City.
compared with 2017’s ED 2.1
Ensure opportunities for locating a variety of desirable, livable wage industries in Spokane that are environmentally compatible with adjacent land uses and support a range of employment types.
The 2026 draft eliminates the human considerations of “desirable, livable-wage industries” and “range of employment types” along with “environmenta[l] compatib[ility] with adjacent land uses.” Do these eliminations serve the “improved well-being and quality of life” of the Spokane community that the August 2026 Introduction sets as its goals?
p. 3 Policy: EP-2.1 Land Supply and Site Selection
Remove barriers to entry for new, expanding, and relocating industries by providing various site-by-site analytics and feasibility information, and implementing incentives.
compared with 2017’s ED 2.1
The City of Spokane encourages development of economic enterprises in locations suited for those uses based upon available public facilities, land capability, neighboring uses, and an orderly development pattern.
Does the 2026 draft’s elimination of “land capability, neighboring uses, and an orderly development pattern” serve the “improved well-being and quality of life” of the Spokane community that the Introduction sets as its goals?
p. 3 Does the 2026 draft’s elimination of the detailed list of specific steps for the City to take concerning land and new income-producing uses in 2017’s ED 2.1 serve the Spokane community?
p. 3 2017’s ED 2.3 Reusable Buildings Inventory
Continue to maintain an inventory of historic and significant older buildings that could be redeveloped for economic activities rather than demolished. has been eliminated. Why? Is an inventory not a helpful tool in promoting re-use? The statement on p. 9 that it is redundant with 2.2 may be questioned, as 2.2 does not recommend an inventory and refers to “sites,” not “buildings.”
p. 3 EP-2.4 Brownfield Redevelopment and EP-2.5 Vacant storefronts The addition of these sections is welcome.
p. 4 EP-3 Resilient, Sustainable, and Diverse Economies; EP-3.1, Economic
Development Plan The addition of ‘resilient’ and ‘those adding to the community and
13

[Source PDF page 161]

cultural identity of Spokane’ and the reorientation of 3.1 to a development plan are welcome.
p. 4 EP-3.2 Economic Diversity The addition of ‘community investments’ is welcome.
p. 4 2017’s ED 3.4 Value Added Business Strategy has been eliminated. Why? The sidebar’s characterizing of this section as putting cabinet makers near lumber sales is inaccurate; it instead fosters the creation of additional jobs here by transforming raw materials into products through value-added work in Spokane rather than sending them elsewhere, e.g. making furniture out of lumber rather than shipping it out raw.
p. 4 EP-3.5 Start-up Support is an appropriate and welcome re-tuning of 2017’s ED 3.3 Enterprise Opportunity.
p. 4 EP-3.6 Home-Based Businesses 2017’s detailed list of potential negative impacts of home-based businesses on the surrounding community to be minimized by development regulations has been eliminated. Why?
p. 4 EP-3.7 Technology-Based Industries The addition of education is welcome; the deletion of quality of life is not.
p. 4 EP-3.9 Regional Marketplace The elimination of the world as an importer of Spokane-made goods is puzzling.
p. 5 EP-3.11 Development Standards and Permitting Process
The current policy focuses on the customer (builder). By contrast, the 2017 ED 3.7 and 7.6 also recognized the City’s responsibility to act on behalf of the community.
ED 7.6 Development Standards and Permitting Process
Periodically evaluate and improve the City of Spokane’s development standards and permitting process to ensure that they are equitable, cost-effective, timely, and meet community needs and goals.
p. 5 EP-3.12 Food Access and Production; EP-3.13 Circular Economy; EP-3.14
Support Local These are welcome new policies that address the importance of local production and of reducing waste.
p. 5 EP-4, Living Wage Jobs and Income Disparity While the considerable detail added relative to 2017’s account is welcome, the substitution of “workforce development” for the “education and training of workers,” which refers to individual human beings increasing their capabilities, is regrettable. pp. 5 and 9 removal of ED-4.2 Benchmark Indicators While the sidebar states that this activity is “already conducted by the City,” the policy’s removal opens the possibility that once it is no longer required by the Comprehensive Plan, the City may cease to conduct it.
p. 6 EP-4.3 Commercial Displacement The addition of this section is welcome.
p. 6 Goal: EP-5 Education and Workforce Development
Improve Spokane’s economy through a qualified, competitive, and diverse labor force
Compare with 2017:
Improve Spokane’s economy through a well-educated citizenry and a qualified labor force that is globally competitive
The deletion of “a well-educated citizenry” as the basis of a globally-competitive labor force is perhaps the clearest example of how the 2026 draft removes education and civic participation from Spokane’s community life.
p. 6 EP-5.1 Youth Programs While 2026’s expansion of the types of programs is
14

[Source PDF page 162]

welcome, the substitution of 2017’s “young people” with “workforce” is not.
p. 6 EP-5.3 Communication Links The addition of the cultural feature is welcome.
p. 6 EP-5.4 Employment Opportunities for All The expansion of this section is welcome.
p. 6 EP-5.5 Libraries as an Educational Resource The downgrading of 2017’s “adequate to improve the educational level” to “help” and the omission of the extensive discussion impoverish this iteration and the opportunities that it should foster. The sidebar’s claim that the policy “has been updated to better match the role of libraries today and to strengthen connection to Economic Development” demonstrates a lack of familiarity with the ways in which libraries currently work and with residents’ use of them in improving their employment prospects.
p. 6 EP-5.6 Environmental Jobs Pipeline The addition of this section is welcome.
p. 7 EP-6 Infrastructure Development and Maintenance, EP-6.1 Investment in
Public Infrastructure 2026’s elimination of 2017’s “the city’s quality of life” as the first goal of public infrastructure projects and the sidebar’s statement that “Goal 6 and its policies have been reworked to focus on economic development, not infrastructure in general” prioritize profit over community.
p. 7 EP-6.4 Growing Communication Infrastructure Needs The addition of this
section is welcome.
p. 7 EP-6.6 Renewable Energy The addition of this section is welcome.
p. 8 EP 7.1 Revenue Sources 2017’s “do not penalize certain types of businesses” has become “do not penalize desired types of businesses.”
p. 8 EP-8 Creative Economy (in the 2017 version more broadly titled Quality of Life and the Environment) The new focus on the creative economy is welcome, while the reduction of creative artists to “workforce” is not. pp. 8-9 2017’s ED 8.1 Quality of Life Protection Protect the natural and built environment as a primary quality of life feature that allows existing businesses to expand and that attracts new businesses, residents, and visitors.
has become
EP-9.1 Promote Regional Natural Resources
Promote the region’s outdoor amenities, recreational opportunities, and agritourism as features of both social benefit and economic growth, while protecting the natural resources for the future.
While the addition of “arts and cultural communities” is welcome, the deletion of the City’s protection of residents’ quality of life and the degradation of nature to a source of profit are not.
pp. 9-10 Policies Removed from the Text The following policies remain relevant and should be re-introduced.
p. 9 ED-2.3 Reusable Buildings Inventory While the sidebar cites EP-2.2 as similar, it refers to “areas” and does not recommend maintaining an inventory.
p. 10 ED 4.2 Benchmark Indicators The sidebar states, “As a policy it does not inform decision making directly.” Why doesn’t it?
p. 10 ED-5.1 K-12 Education While the sidebar states, The City is unable to influence school curricula. Other policies remaining in the chapter allow for interaction with students.
15

[Source PDF page 163]

the policy recommends only that the City “work cooperatively with local schools to help maintain and enhance the quality” of education and “[s]upport efforts to introduce new, high-quality programs into the curricula.” The City is able to do this by setting a tone and other indirect methods.
p. 10 ED-5.6 Employer Training Support While the sidebar states, The City does not have the ability/tools necessary to directly influence how employers train their staff.
the policy does not recommend an effort to directly influence but to “encourage employers to support continuing education and training for their employees.” The sidebar statement ignores this draft’s own recommendations for training in EP-3.5 “Promote incubator and accelerator programs that provide support such as mentorship, training and education” and EP-3.7 “Assist the development of advanced and emerging technology- based industries by supporting education.”
p. 10 ED 7.1 Collaborative Nurturing of the Business Climate
Work with the business community, labor, economic development organizations and residents to maintain a good business climate.
This policy provides a useful tool.
Chapter 8 Urban Design and Historic Preservation
The chapter’s increased articulation of ‘people-oriented’ design and of the value of historic preservation and the addition of sustainability, climate, and accessibility considerations are welcome. The extensive excising of neighborhoods is not and should be reversed. Moreover, the Future Land Use Map applying the Comprehensive Plan as published in early August intrudes Residential High density into registered historic districts, working counter to DP-1.1 Landmark Structures, Buildings, and Sites.
Recognize and preserve significant landmark structures, buildings, and sites.
p. 3 DP-1.3 Significant Views and Vistas
The policy praises the City’s recognition of significant views and vista as “providing protection from encroachment or adverse impacts” but gives no definition of “encroachment” and “adverse impacts” and no details of how this protection will be provided. It should have added to it the clear measures of the 2017 statement:
protect them by establishing appropriate development regulations for nearby undeveloped properties
p. 3 DP-1.6 Design Review Process “Apply design guidelines to significant projects through a review process, such as the Design Review Board.” How will ‘significant’ be defined? Now that the Design Review Board has been abolished, what review processes will be utilized? Who will choose or devise them?
p. 3 DP-1.7 Balance Requirements with Need This is a welcome new policy.
p. 3 DP-1.9 Design Principles for Public Projects and Structures
“Design and construct public facilities and structures using the highest design principles to maximize public benefit and encourage similar improvements to the built environment.”
Compare with 2017’s consideration of “neighborhood compatibility,” which has been deleted:
DP 2.3 Design Standards for Public Projects and Structures
Design all public projects and structures to uphold the highest design standards and
16

[Source PDF page 164]

neighborhood compatibility.
Discussion: The development of public projects and structures can have an impact on surrounding areas. The perception that this has not been considered has resulted in neighborhood opposition to projects, in spite of potential benefits. In order to mitigate the perceived negative impacts on a neighborhood, the city must serve as an example by building its facilities to make a positive visual and functional contribution to the neighborhood, rather than just trying to mitigate negative impacts.
p. 4 DP-1.11 Building and Site Design 2026 deletes 2017’s “intensity of use” as among the features to be considered to ensure that new projects are “compatible with the visual character of the surrounding environment.”
p. 4 DP-1.15 Diversity of Design in the Built Environment This is a welcome new policy.
p. 4 DP-1.17 Urban Trees and Landscaping in All Development The addition of a requirement “that new development incorporate natural elements where appropriate” is welcome, though enforcement will require a definition of ‘appropriate’.
p. 5 DP-2 Historic Preservation How will the new draft plan’s emphasis on Urban Hubs be coordinated with historic preservation?
p. 5 DP-2.3 Historic Preservation Plan This is a welcome new policy and should include features concerning the placement of Urban Hubs respecting historic preservation.
p. 6 DP-2.7 Equitable Communities This is a welcome new policy.
p. 6 DP-2.9 Preservation through Tribal Coordination The expansion of this policy is welcome.
p. 7 DP-2.13 Incentives toward Reuse, Renovation, and Preservation This is a welcome new policy.
p. 7 DP-2.15, Rehabilitation Education and Assistance The introduction of education into rehabilitation is welcome but the excising of “provide” (DP-3.9) from incentives is not.
p. 7 DP-2.16, Historic Districts compare with 2017:
DP 3.13 Historic Districts and Neighborhoods
A signal instance of the excising of neighborhoods from the Comprehensive Plan. It should be reversed.
p. 7 DP-2.17 Affordable Housing This is a welcome new policy.
p. 8 DP-2.18 Avoid Displacement and DP-2.19 Protection from Climate Hazards are
welcome new policies.
pp. 8-9 DP-3 Sustainable Development This new goal and its policies are welcome.
p. 9 DP-3.10 Natural Features and Habitat Protection is a welcome re-introduction. pp. 9-10 DP-4 Inclusive Design This new goal and much of the policy language are welcome, but see comment to DP-4.3.
p. 10 2017’s DP 2.14 Town Squares and Plazas has been eliminated from 2026. A sidebar states that DP-4.3 “incorporates concepts from it.” But its most important concepts of ‘requirement’ and ‘placement around buildings’ (Require redevelopment areas and new development to provide appropriately scaled open space such as town squares, plazas, or other public or private spaces that can be used as the focus of commercial and civic buildings.) are missing and should be restored.
p. 10 The following two excised goals should be re-introduced because the other sections
17

[Source PDF page 165]

cited in the sidebar as addressing the issues do not address them adequately.
DP 4 Downtown Center Viability
Goal: Create a vital, livable downtown by maintaining it as the region’s economic and cultural center and preserving and reinforcing its historic and distinctly urban character.
DP 5 Local Determination
Goal: Make neighborhoods attractive, safe places by encouraging residents to express their design and development values.
DP 5.1 Neighborhood Participation
Encourage resident participation in planning and development processes that will shape or re-shape the physical character of their neighborhood.
DP 5.2 Neighborhood Involvement in the City Design Review Process
Encourage neighborhoods to participate in the city’s design review process.
Chapter 9 Natural Environment
The extensive additions to this chapter and articulation of various issues in a nature- centered way are welcome developments. The removal of policies recognizing the importance of the natural environment to quality of life and to public life are not. To this chapter should be added cross-references to the material on wildfires that has been added to other chapters of the Comprehensive Plan.
p. 2 Introduction par. 3 slightly re-written
p. 2 NE-1.2 Stormwater Techniques and Best Practices sidebar: “This policy was added” should read “This policy was expanded”; a similar policy existed in 2017, here expanded with “Best Practices.”
p. 3 NE-1.5 Mining Activities 2017’s “Prohibit open pit mining...” has become “Prohibit or severely limit open pit mining...”
Who will decide whether it is prohibit or severely limit? On what basis? With what public process? Why has this option been opened up? What kind of open pit mining would this change allow?
p. 3 NE-1.8 Toxic Dumping Regulations 2017’s “Retain and enforce laws against dumping toxic fluids...” has become “Develop and enforce restrictions and fines for the dumping of toxic fluids... consistent with state and federal law.” The 2017 verb ‘retain’ connotes a City law, because you cannot retain something over which you do not have final authority. The proposed 2026 wording cedes that authority to the state and the federal government, entities over which the City has no control. There are no guarantees that the state and the federal government will provide as much protection to residents of Spokane as the city government that they alone elect. Why can the City not simply continue to enforce those laws?
p. 3 NE-1.9 Sewer Requirement sidebar: “The original mention of the urban growth area was made more specific, limiting this policy to the City’s service area.” What sewer requirements are there for the urban growth area outside the City’s service area? If there are none, does that create a risk of contamination reaching the aquifer?
pp. 3-4 NE-2 Water Conservation The strengthening of this goal and its policies is a welcome and needed development.
p. 5 NE-3.5 Aquatic and Upland Habitat The specification of conditions for anadromous fish is a welcome addition.
18

[Source PDF page 166]

p. 7 NE-6 Natural Landforms to ‘including landforms of cultural significance’ should be added ‘and ecological’ (including landforms of cultural and ecological significance)
p. 8 NE-9.2 Natural Corridor Links and Connections The restitution of the phrase “natural areas” (i.e. the removal of the adjective “undisturbed” that appeared in the May version of the chapter) is welcome.
p. 9 NE-9.6 Interconnected Natural Systems This new policy is welcome. pp. 10-11 NE-10 Urban Forestry This new goal and its expanded and added goals are welcome.
p. 10 NE-11 Connectivity and Access to Wildlands and Open Space This new goal and the added and expanded policies are welcome.
p. 11 NE-13.3 Critical Areas Education This new policy is welcome.
p. 12 NE-13.6 Volunteer Opportunities This new policy is welcome.
p. 12 NE-14 Tribal Collaboration This new goal and its policies are welcome.
p. 12 NE-15, Data and Monitoring This new goal and its policies are welcome.
Policies Removed from the Text The following removed policies are worth restoring.
p. 13 NE-13 Incorporating Natural Designs in Public Places The sidebar’s statement that this goal has been transferred to Chapter 8 as policy 3.9 dismisses its location here, which recognizes the natural environment’s contribution to public life.
p. 14 NE-9.6 Packaging Reduction The sidebar states that it implements other policies but does not name them.
p. 14 NE-9.7 Spokane’s Youth and Green Economy Careers The removal of this policy fails to capitalize on green careers as a growing trend that will be especially important and appealing to young people.
p. 14 NE-16 Quality of Life The sidebar’s statement that this goal and policies were re- located to Chapter 10 dismisses the importance of its location here, which recognizes the natural environment’s contribution to quality of life.
p. 15 NE-16X Energy Conservation The sidebar states that this goal was a new one drafted for inclusion but that it was later removed because the related policies were removed or relocated. However, energy conservation is integral to the treatment of the natural environment.
Chapter 10 Community Health
The change in title from Social Health to Community Health appropriately reflects the chapter’s contents.
p. 2 CH-1 Funding Mechanisms to Support Community Health; CH-1.1 Invest in
Social Health
The role of the arts and cultural programs that 2017 recognized here has been transferred to CH-3 Public Art.
p. 2 CH-1.2 Commitment to Youth The expanded reach of this policy is a welcome development.
p. 3 CH-1.4 Community Awareness and Access While the expanded list of means of communication is welcome, the removal of the recommendation of reduced rates and financial support for memberships represents a loss.
p. 3 CH-1.6 Inclusive Community Involvement, CH-1.7 Equitable Investments for
Community Resilience These new policies are a welcome addition.
p. 3 2017’s SH 1.8 Volunteerism has been removed but not included in the list of
19

[Source PDF page 167]

removed polices on p. 12. Its removal represents a loss to the community.
p. 4 CH-2.5 Childcare and Public Facilities This new policy of locating childcare facilities within public facilities is a welcome addition.
p. 4 CH-3 Public Art The division of CH-3, formerly “the arts” inclusive of a traditional notion of culture, into CH-3 Public Art (generally visual and sculptural) and CH-4 Celebrating Spokane’s Many Cultures brings a welcome development of the latter, though a narrowing of the definition of the former.
p. 4 CH-3.1 Municipal Arts Plan This welcome new policy calls for a plan to promote public art and local art programs to augment both economy and quality of life.
p. 4 CH-3.2 Support for the Arts 2017’s “Encourage public and private participation in and support of the arts and cultural events” is narrowed to “public art.” The term ‘public art’ is understood to mean works of visual art such as murals, sculptures, etc., whereas “arts and cultural events” covers the broader spectrum enumerated in 2017’s discussion:
“written, visual, musical, traditional, and performing arts.”
p. 5 CH-3.3 Neighborhood Arts Presence The addition of Neighborhood Councils to
the organizations to work with is welcome, although the deletion of 2017’s lengthy section on the importance of neighborhood art to the character, identity, and atmosphere of the neighborhood is a loss.
p. 5 CH-3.4 Public Funding for the Arts The broadening of sources beyond Tax Increment Financing is welcome. Although retaining 2017’s “the Arts” in the title, what seems to be meant here is better referred to with “art” in the meaning of visual or sculptural art, which also seems to be the referent of “the arts in public projects...”
p. 5 CH-3.5 Support for Local Artists, CH-3.6 Artist and Maker Spaces The
expansion of the first of these policies and the addition of the second are welcome. pp. 5-6 CH-4 Celebrating Spokane’s Many Cultures This new section with largely new material, especially 4.1 Cultural Master Plan and 4.6 Tribal Connectedness, brings a welcome inclusion of Spokane’s many cultures.
p. 7 CH-5.3 Diversity Awareness and Education, CH-6.3, Supporting Unhoused and
Unstably Housed Neighbors These are welcome new policies.
p. 7 CH-6.4 Quality of Life Indicators The relocation of this section to Chapter 10 Community Health from Chapter 9 Natural Environment represents a gain for Chapter 10 and a loss for Chapter 9. A cross-reference should be added to Chapter 9.
p. 8 CH-7.4 Public Safety and Human Services This new policy is a welcome addition. pp. 9-10 CH-9 Food Access and Security The numerous new policies and updates in this section (9.4-9.10) are welcome.
pp. 10-11 CH-10 Emergency Management and related policies The addition of this section is particularly welcome because of its vital importance to the community.
p. 12 Policies Removed from the Text recommended for restoration Policy: SH-3.4, One Percent for Arts
Encourage private developers to incorporate an arts presence into buildings and other permanent structures with a value of over $25,000 by allocating one percent of their project’s budget for this purpose.
sidebar: SH-3.4 was removed because it is more appropriately addressed as an implementation strategy, not a policy.
This policy should be retained as an indication of the City’s expectation that developers contribute to the arts locally.
20

[Source PDF page 168]

Policy: SH-5.3, Space for Public Benefit Uses
Provide regulatory and tax incentives and flexibility that encourage builders, developers, and businesses to make space available in their project for public benefit uses. sidebar: The sharing of facilities is captured in other policies.
The sharing of facilities may be captured in other policies but not the overt call to builders, developers, and businesses. This policy should be restored to indicate the expectation that they fulfill their role in developing space for public benefit uses.
Policy: SH-6.6, Neighborhood Role
Encourage neighborhood residents to apply CTPED principles in their consideration of development issues within their own particular neighborhood. sidebar: The topic of SH-6.6 is covered in Urban Design and Historic Preservation (e.g. people-oriented design) and Neighborhoods (e.g. safe mobility).
This policy should be retained in this chapter because it specifically involves CTPED principles and it demonstrates an important way in which residents can become involved in their neighborhood and participate in addressing neighborhood issues.
Chapter 11 Neighborhoods
The four additional instances of “Neighborhood Council[s]” relative to the April draft are welcome.
• p. 2 The Introduction adds a cross-reference to the description of the role of Neighborhood Councils in the Local Governance Through Civic Participation
Chapter.
• p. 6 “neighborhood councils” has been added to N-6.3 Maintenance of City- Owned Open Space and Amenities
• p. 6 “Neighborhood Councils” has been added to N-7.2 Neighborhood Planning
• p. 6 A cross-reference to the role of Neighborhood Councils in the Local Governance Through Civic Participation Chapter in the marginal notes.
p. 2 2017’s Values section provided a detailed list of the attractive features of Spokane’s varied and unique neighborhoods and how to preserve and enhance them. The current draft lacks that section.
p. 3 2017’s N-2.1 Neighborhood Quality of Life included “quality schools” in the list of options constituting it. The current draft omits it.
p. 3 The current draft’s additional 2.6 Housing Diversity specifies “the development of moderate density housing options in all neighborhoods.”
p. 5 N-4.7 Safe Mobility This policy adds welcome new features that promote safety for users of active transportation.
p. 6 2017’s N-6.1 Environmental Planning included environmental planning as “a daily exercise in maintaining a clean living environment for health, safety, and aesthetic purposes” in addition to its use in new or renewed developments. The current draft does not.
p. 6 2017’s N-8 Neighborhood Planning Process goal includes in its description of the “neighborhood planning process” that it “empowers neighborhoods in their decision- making.” The current draft, in which the section is now 7, does not.
p. 6 2017’s N-8.2 Neighborhood Planning Process states that it “carries out the city’s firm commitment to neighborhood planning, involves simultaneous consideration of city and neighborhood goals and strategies, and includes representatives of both the city and
21

[Source PDF page 169]

neighborhood working together.” The current draft, in which the section is now 7, does not.
pp. 6-7 References to ongoing planning by neighborhoods have been removed from 2017’s policies 8.3 City Participation in Neighborhood Planning required that neighborhoods, when they plan, consult with the City so that their plans will not conflict with the plans of various governmental entities. Similarly, 8.4 Consistency of Plans was concerned with “consistency between neighborhood planning documents and the comprehensive plan.” See also 2017’s Appendix H Neighborhood Planning. The current draft’s section 7.3 is now entitled Plan Consistency and Implementation and no longer alludes to ongoing planning by neighborhoods but instructs the City to take “adopted plans” into consideration when the City plans “including during Comprehensive Plan Amendments and updates.” 7.4 has been re-titled Connections and Impacts Between and Among Neighborhoods and instructs to “Consider the impacts of decisions on both the neighborhood most directly involved and how neighborhoods are interconnected and relate to each other when conducting planning or policy/code amendments.”
p. 7 2017 contained Policy 8.5 Neighborhood Planning Coordination and 8.6
Neighborhood Planning Recommendations detailing procedures for the plans made by neighborhoods in relation to one another and to the City. These policies do not appear in the current draft and are not listed among the Policies removed from the text on p. 7.
p. 7 Policies Removed from the Text recommended for re-introduction Policy: N-6.2, Code Enforcement Enforce the city codes for public nuisances impacting neighborhood properties.
City enforcement of its codes is a common issue for Spokane’s residents.
Chapter 12 Parks and Recreation
The greater attention to the preservation of the natural environment in much of the chapter is a welcome development. There are some concerns, however. Policy 2.3 Connecting the River and Adjacent Uses could easily come into conflict with the mandate to preserve the natural environment. A feature that will complicate the policies in this chapter is the definition in Chapter 3 Growth Strategy (pp. 9-10) that includes indoor facilities such as sports complexes in “open space.”
p. 2 First paragraph re-written to emphasize parks and open spaces.
p. 3 PR-2 Parks and Open Space System The effect of this goal and its “opportunities for passive and active recreation provided by a comprehensive open space network” is complicated by the new definition of Open Space in Chapter 3 Growth Strategy (pp. 9- 10), which conflates the formerly separate “Conservation Open Space” and “Open Space” (cf. 2017 Chapter Three Land Use, p. 45) and includes in it “active recreation facilities (e.g. sports complexes).” Thus under the new Open Space designation, a former Conservation Space that offered important wildlife habitat could have a stadium with a parking lot built on it.
p. 3 PR 2.3 Connecting the River and Adjacent Uses “Study and develop ways to enhance the river by coordinating access and use of the waterways in Spokane with access to adjacent uses and opportunities, such as providing river access for both people and watercraft adjacent to shops and restaurants.” PR 2.3 is likely to give rise to two issues. Is “access” defined as public or private (e.g. a privately-owned marina or dock)? If private, will it be allowed to interfere with public
22

[Source PDF page 170]

forms of access, such as the Centennial Trail? There is likely to be conflict between 2.3 and PR-1.2 River Corridors, which mandates maintaining consistency with habitat preservation and protection standards. Increased access to the river from commercial venues may “enhance” it for human customers but will very likely degrade its environmental and habitat quality. Any conflict between the application of these two policies must be resolved in favor of PR-1.2. There is already extensive access to the river for humans who wish it.
p. 4 PR-2.4 Parks and Recreation Amenities De ve lo p a n d m a in ta in p a rks a n d re cre a tio n a m e n itie s, in clu d in g b u t n ot lim ite d to in te rp re tive a re a s, sp o rts co m p le xe s a n d fie ld s, stru ctu re d p la y a re a s, p u b lic ga rd e n s, a n d e n te rta in m e n t ve n u e s, th a t p ro vid e b e n e fits to b o th re sid e n ts a n d visito rs a n d e n h a n ce th e lo ca l e co n o m y.
Will this policy diminish the park space available to Spokane residents for their own personal and group activities?
p. 4 PR-2.7 Efficient Property Management Assess unimproved park land holdings within the city and, considering Level-of-Service (LOS) standards, develop modifications and solutions to increase LOS benefiting residents.
Will this policy reduce the open space available to Spokane residents, especially children, to use for their own free-form recreation?
p. 5 PR-3.5 Community Gardens This is a welcome new policy.
p. 5 PR-4.3 Innovative Trail Development Techniques This is a welcome new policy.
p. 6 PR-6.2 Celebrate Local Landscapes and Build Resilience and PR-6.3 Park
Equity and Investments are welcome new polices.
p. 7 PR-7.3 Park Funding Consider all potential funding sources to maintain and enhance the adopted Level-of-Service (LOS) standards for parks, seeking funding in addition to the general fund contribution to Parks and Recreation.
Does this policy open the door to private funding of the maintenance of Spokane’s parks?
If so, this is a serious change in practice that must be brought to the public for a vote.
p. 8 Policies Removed from the Text recommended for restoration PR-3.7 Outdoor Recreational Facilities Provide facilities and programs that allow the public the opportunity to participate in a broad range of outdoor recreational activities, including expanding the hours and dates these locations are available where feasible. sidebar: PR-3.7 (originally PRS-5.6) being removed as it is redundant with PR-1.2
[N.B. PR-1.2 River Corridors “Recognize, enhance, and preserve access to the Spokane
River and various waterways for the recreational enjoyment and use of the public, recognizing the health, social, and cultural benefits access to the waters of Spokane provides, while maintaining consistency with habitat preservation and protection standards.”]
PR-1.2 deals specifically with waterways and therefore there does not appear to be redundant with PR-3.7.
PR-7.7 Public Participation Ensure that decisions regarding the city’s park and open space system encourage the full participation of Spokane’s citizenry [residents].
This policy should be restored, as in every chapter, to allow the Charter-mandated role of residents and Neighborhood Councils in the range of City decisions.
Chapter 13 Governance
23

[Source PDF page 171]

The enhancement of pre-existing goals and the addition of new ones in LG-1, the emphasis on broad community participation, the addition of details to the section on Neighborhood Councils, and the addition of Goals LG-7 Community Participation and LG-8 Tribal and Urban Native Collaboration and policies are welcome developments.
p. 2 Introduction 2017’s statement of the “tremendous impacts” made by community members’ participation in local government has been excised.
p. 3 LG-1.6 Equity as Core Principle and LG-1.7 Incorporating Data Analysis are
welcome new policies.
p. 3 2017’s LGC 2 Citizen-Directed Decisions has been renamed Community Involvement, reflecting a weaker role for residents in decision-making as seen in LG 2.2.
p. 3 2017’s LGC 2.2 Civics Education Throughout Life opened the Discussion portion with the affirmation, “Individual citizens participating in community planning activities bear a substantial responsibility for the success of these activities. It requires their exercise of initiative, discipline, thought, and communication.” The current draft’s LG 2.2 Civics Education refers to “responsive civic participation” and “engaged community.”
p. 4 The “Visions and Values” section of the 2017 update opened with the statement that “Spokane volunteers involved in the planning process identified important themes in relation to Spokane’s current and future growth.” The current draft eliminates that section and contains no similar statement.
p. 4 LG-3.4 Community Representation This new policy encouraging participation of a broad range of community members in Neighborhood Councils is welcome.
p. 5 2017’s LGC 6.1 Enforcement of Land Use and Development Codes contains a Discussion section affirming that, “One of the fundamental principles of effective governance is to ensure responsiveness to the needs of citizens. Through the planning process, citizens express their desired quality of life and the features of the physical, social, and economic environments that characterize that quality of life. Land use and development codes are governmental tools to achieve those features.” The current draft’s LG-6.1 omits the Discussion section and refers to “compliance with land use and development codes that support quality of life, increase responsiveness, and provide equitable enforcement.”
p. 6 LG-7 Community Participation with its policies LG-7.1 Awareness of Opportunities, LG-7.2 Partner with Organizations, and LG-7.3 Environmental
Awareness are welcome additions.
pp. 6-7 LG-8 Tribal and Urban Native Collaboration with its policies LG-8.1 Intergovernmental Relations, LG-8.2 Tribal Consultation, LG-8.3 Tribal Liaisons
and LG-8.4 Urban Native Collaboration are welcome additions.
Appendix 1 Public Participation and Engagement Appendix
The appendix contains copies of the materials related to the broad public outreach through workshops and other gatherings prepared by the Planning Department, which does not identify work with advisory and focus groups (see instead 2017’s Appendix I Public Outreach, Participation and Coordination).
Appendix 2 Climate Element Matrix Appendix
24

[Source PDF page 172]

This appendix gathers together and identifies elements in all the chapters relating to climate issues with icons identifying particular topics.
Appendix 3 Transportation
not yet complete
Appendix 4 Capital Facilities Plan
This lengthy appendix provides technical information.
Appendix 5 Housing
This appendix contains reports and documents concerning various issues around housing (with the exception of the Emergency Housing and Permanent Affordable Housing Supplement, which will be completed and entered prior to the Plan Commission hearing).
Volume 3 Shoreline Chapter Tech Data
contains documents and reports from the 2006-2007 Shoreline Master Program Update
25

[Source PDF page 173]

RE: Resolution concerning Safeguarding Neighborhood Livability
Safeguarding Neighborhood Livability through sensible development protocols and ensuring Spokane Municipal Code is followed.
Whereas, Spokane neighborhoods are being negatively affected by developments moving forward without sensible protocols or adherence to Spokane Municipal Code and
Whereas, developments are substantially increasing traffic from residents, visitors, emergency vehicles, school buses, delivery services, utility providers, and construction vehicles; and
Whereas, Spokane Municipal Code Section 17H.010.040(C) exempts certain developments
from road paving requirements when the property was platted prior to 2006; and
Whereas, this exemption allows a significant new residential development to proceed without requiring the corresponding roadway improvements that would normally accompany a development of this size; and
Whereas, safe and adequately maintained streets are essential public infrastructure that benefit both existing residents and future homeowners by improving safety, accessibility, emergency response, and long-term neighborhood sustainability; and
Whereas, when developers are not required to construct or improve the infrastructure necessary to support new development, the responsibility and financial burden may ultimately fall upon the City and its taxpayers; and
Whereas, residents have also experienced significant impacts from construction activities, including excavation and other heavy construction beginning as early as 6:00 am and as late as 10 pm including weekends; and
Whereas, loud construction activities and excessive noise have substantially affected the quiet enjoyment of neighboring properties and have impacted residents' ability to rest, work from home, spend time with their families, and enjoy their homes; and
Whereas, the current construction schedule allows work to occur seven days per week, resulting in little or no respite for surrounding residents; and

[Source PDF page 174]

Whereas, Spokane has an interest in encouraging responsible development while also protecting the health, safety, and quality of life of established neighborhoods.
Whereas, meaningful protections for neighborhoods are most effective when applied not only to future developments but also, to the fullest extent permitted by law, to developments that are currently underway and have not yet received final approval or completed construction; and
Whereas, consistent enforcement of Spokane Municipal Code and applicable development regulations is essential to ensuring compliance, maintaining public confidence, and preventing unfair advantages for developers who fail to meet legal requirements; and
Whereas, residents affected by nearby development often face significant challenges navigating City processes, reporting violations, obtaining timely responses, and protecting their interests during the construction process, creating a need for independent neighborhood advocacy and assistance.
Therefore, Be It Resolved:
That the Community Assembly respectfully request that the Spokane City Council:
1. Review Spokane Municipal Code Section 17H.010.040(C) and consider amending the code so that developments adding a substantial number of new residential units be required to construct or contribute to the paving of adjacent public roads, regardless of when the property was originally platted
2. Require developers to have current Spokane City business licenses and current contractors’ licenses before initiating development
3. Require developers to have required permits in place before logging and grading, obstructing streets, and to have other required permits before initiating development
4. Evaluate and insure that current development regulations adequately require that infrastructure improvements be proportional to the impacts created by new residential development
5. Review and strengthen construction noise regulations to better protect surrounding neighborhoods from excessive early morning, late evening, and weekend construction activities
6. Establish reasonable limits on weekend construction hours and the use of amplified music at construction sites located adjacent to residential neighborhoods
7. Ensure that future developments be balanced with appropriate infrastructure improvements and neighborhood protections so that growth occurs in a manner that will serve both new and existing residents
8. Ensure that residents are provided consistent access to development plans, secured permits and other documents regarding developments
9. Establish a designated City staff person and department responsible for addressing neighborhood concerns and code violations including on weekends.
10. Apply any adopted amendments, regulations, and development standards resulting from this resolution, to the fullest extent permitted by law, to all development projects that are

[Source PDF page 175]

currently underway and have not received final occupancy approval or completed all required public infrastructure improvements, in addition to future development projects
11. Establish and enforce meaningful civil penalties, fines, stop-work orders, permit suspensions, or other appropriate enforcement actions against developers, contractors, or property owners who violate Spokane Municipal Code, permit conditions, approved development plans, environmental regulations, construction-hour restrictions, noise regulations, or other applicable City requirements
12. Require that repeated or willful violations result in escalating penalties sufficient to deter noncompliance and recover the City's costs of enforcement
13. Encourage residents to work through established City processes by bringing concerns to their Neighborhood Council and if appropriate to the relevant committee of the Community Assembly, appropriate City committees, or relevant City departments. These bodies can help facilitate communication between residents, developers and City staff, monitor compliance with applicable regulations, and ensure that reported code violations or neighborhood impacts are reviewed and addressed through the appropriate channels
14. Require regular public reporting regarding code enforcement activities, complaints received, investigations conducted, violations identified, penalties assessed, and corrective actions taken for residential development projects
15. Ensure that residents have accessible, timely, and transparent opportunities to report violations and receive updates regarding enforcement actions throughout the duration of development projects.
The Community Assembly respectfully requests that these matters be referred to the appropriate City departments and committees for review and that recommendations for possible code amendments be presented to the Spokane City Council.