Betsy Bradley | 2025-12-04 (City log)
Source: City of Spokane, Assembled PlanSpokane Comments (October 2 packet).
Packet record C024-P033 | PDF pages 184, 185.
Reviewed reading copy. Personal contact details are omitted.
[Source PDF page 184]
Comments on the Urban Design & Historic Preservation chapter of PlanSpokane 2046
Betsy Bradley’s comments are indented
Policy: DP-1.1, Landmark Structures, Buildings, and Sites
Add districts to align with existing ordinance and text in the historic preservation section below
Policy: DP-1.4, Gateway Identity and Physical Elements
The popularity of gateway elements started some 20 years ago and seems a bit artificial and out-of-date these days. We don’t need them, they are artificial and they seldom contribute to sense of place as they have no meaning to residents.
Policy DP-1.5, Urban Design Principles
Policy: DP-1.6, Design Review Process
These goals are trumped by the requirement that all standards must be quantifiable.
Quality of life matters involve experiencing the places being reviewed and are inherently qualitative. The phrase “community input and expertise of design professionals” suggests regard for what citizens’ recognize as quality of life but situates decision making firmly in professionals’ purview. It is rather misleading and there is no effective mechanism to consider citizens’ quality of life expectations. Testimony at public hearings is too late and is disregarded. There is that phrase “no one wants this.” But it maps well and meets quantifiable factors and hence is approved.
Policy: DP-1.7, Balance Requirements with Need
At first glance, this policy seems to be what we all would want. However, on closer reading it supports developers’ lobbying for avoiding the costs of off-street parking and other expenses, particularly those associated with new housing. Again: how will the needs and wants of Spokane’s residents be assessed and presented? Public input at public hearings is too late and not taken to heart.
Policy: DP-1.8, Design Review as Part of the Permit Process
The phrase “design needs of the city” cannot be defined. Who in the city: the developer? Nearby residents? The Home Builders?
Policy: DP-2.1, Historic Preservation as a High Priority
Bradley comments 1
[Source PDF page 185]
Replace establish with maintain as anyone with an understanding of the role of historic preservation in Spokane during the last decades knows this is the case.
Policy: DP-2.5, Identification and Protection of Resources
Identify historic resources to inform decision making in City departments through the maintenance of an inventory of historic properties…
This is an unrealistic proposal for these reasons:
There is no funding for a complete survey.
Individuals list properties in the Spokane register to use economic incentives and hence the register is an un-managed list of significant properties and always will be.
If a survey includes evaluations of historic significance, it has a limited usefulness over time as understandings about what is significant by citizens and professionals changes.
There is no rational basis for a “once and done” approach to identifying historic properties any more than not changing zoning to meet current interests and needs.
Policy: DP-2.12, Legislative Priorities for Preserving Historic Buildings
Consider adding: oppose state preemption and maintain local decision-making concerning historic preservation and land use decisions.
Bradley comments 2
Betsy Bradley | 2025-12-04 (City log)
Source: City of Spokane, Assembled PlanSpokane Comments (October 2 packet).
Packet record C024-P033 | PDF pages 184, 185.
Reviewed reading copy. Personal contact details are omitted.
[Source PDF page 184]
Comments on the Urban Design & Historic Preservation chapter of PlanSpokane 2046
Betsy Bradley’s comments are indented
Policy: DP-1.1, Landmark Structures, Buildings, and Sites
Add districts to align with existing ordinance and text in the historic preservation section below
Policy: DP-1.4, Gateway Identity and Physical Elements
The popularity of gateway elements started some 20 years ago and seems a bit artificial and out-of-date these days. We don’t need them, they are artificial and they seldom contribute to sense of place as they have no meaning to residents.
Policy DP-1.5, Urban Design Principles
Policy: DP-1.6, Design Review Process
These goals are trumped by the requirement that all standards must be quantifiable.
Quality of life matters involve experiencing the places being reviewed and are inherently qualitative. The phrase “community input and expertise of design professionals” suggests regard for what citizens’ recognize as quality of life but situates decision making firmly in professionals’ purview. It is rather misleading and there is no effective mechanism to consider citizens’ quality of life expectations. Testimony at public hearings is too late and is disregarded. There is that phrase “no one wants this.” But it maps well and meets quantifiable factors and hence is approved.
Policy: DP-1.7, Balance Requirements with Need
At first glance, this policy seems to be what we all would want. However, on closer reading it supports developers’ lobbying for avoiding the costs of off-street parking and other expenses, particularly those associated with new housing. Again: how will the needs and wants of Spokane’s residents be assessed and presented? Public input at public hearings is too late and not taken to heart.
Policy: DP-1.8, Design Review as Part of the Permit Process
The phrase “design needs of the city” cannot be defined. Who in the city: the developer? Nearby residents? The Home Builders?
Policy: DP-2.1, Historic Preservation as a High Priority
Bradley comments 1
[Source PDF page 185]
Replace establish with maintain as anyone with an understanding of the role of historic preservation in Spokane during the last decades knows this is the case.
Policy: DP-2.5, Identification and Protection of Resources
Identify historic resources to inform decision making in City departments through the maintenance of an inventory of historic properties…
This is an unrealistic proposal for these reasons:
There is no funding for a complete survey.
Individuals list properties in the Spokane register to use economic incentives and hence the register is an un-managed list of significant properties and always will be.
If a survey includes evaluations of historic significance, it has a limited usefulness over time as understandings about what is significant by citizens and professionals changes.
There is no rational basis for a “once and done” approach to identifying historic properties any more than not changing zoning to meet current interests and needs.
Policy: DP-2.12, Legislative Priorities for Preserving Historic Buildings
Consider adding: oppose state preemption and maintain local decision-making concerning historic preservation and land use decisions.
Bradley comments 2