Eme Ray | 2026-10-02
Source: City of Spokane, Assembled PlanSpokane Comments (October 2 packet).
Packet record C444-P570 | PDF pages 1535, 1536, 1537, 1538, 1539, 1540, 1541, 1542, 1543, 1544.
Reviewed reading copy. Personal contact details are omitted.

Subject as filed: PlanSpokane 2046 Public Comments – Vinegar Flats Corridor-Focused Growth Alternative

[Source PDF page 1535]

Hi PlanSpokane Team
Attached is a Corridor-Focused Growth Alternative for Vinegar Flats that I am submitting for consideration as an alternative to the current draft Future Land Use Map.
What this proposal is—and what it is not
This is not a request for Vinegar Flats to avoid growth. The alternative still represents a substantial increase in development opportunity over today's baseline. It proposes concentrating that growth primarily along Inland Empire Way, where an Urban Hub can function as an identifiable corridor, while targeting Residential High to locations better suited to greater intensity and maximizing Agriculture toward Latah Creek. The concept also provides a purposeful exception around Wentel Grant Park/Parkside, where additional depth can support parking and neighborhood- and park-serving uses.
The scale of growth
What we continue to question is the scale of growth being assigned to this small, geographically contained valley and why that amount is necessary.
The City's current alternatives would increase the MIX/RH acreage shown for Vinegar Flats from a baseline of 8.5 acres to approximately 72.6–77 acres. Our alternative still increases that acreage to an estimated 37–39 acres—more than four times the baseline—but does so in a much more focused pattern.
Baseline MIX/RH 8.5 acres
City's current alternatives ~72.6–77 acres
Corridor-Focused Alternative ~37–39 acres (more than 4× baseline)
We continue to believe that Vinegar Flats is being asked to absorb an extraordinary amount of higher-intensity land use relative to the scale and constraints of this neighborhood. However, we have not been provided with the information necessary to evaluate that concern quantitatively.
We have repeatedly asked:
what housing or population capacity Vinegar Flats is expected to accommodate, what share of the City's overall growth need that represents, and how the scale and distribution shown on this map were determined.

[Source PDF page 1536]

We still do not have those answers.
That is particularly concerning when the City itself identifies a need to accommodate almost 22,400 additional housing units citywide through 2046. Without a quantified objective for Vinegar Flats, we have no meaningful way to determine why 72–77 acres of MIX/RH are necessary here, whether a smaller amount could accomplish the same objective, or how our neighborhood's proposed growth compares with what is being asked of other areas of Spokane.
The public-engagement process
I also want to address the public-engagement process directly.
I have spent much of my professional life facilitating groups, and I believe there is a fundamental problem with the way this conversation has been structured for Vinegar Flats.
Meaningful engagement requires more than presenting people with a map and asking whether they like it. Before asking a community to respond to a proposed solution, participants need to understand the problem they are being asked to help solve:
What are the objectives?
What constraints are we working within?
How much growth needs to be accommodated here?
Why this amount?
What alternatives were considered?
What is negotiable, and what is not?
Those are not peripheral questions. They are the information people need in order to participate intelligently in the conversation.
Our neighborhood formed a planning committee, held meetings, gathered approximately 90 written responses, discussed what residents value and want to preserve, and attempted in good faith to understand where those priorities align with the City's objectives. Our adopted neighborhood resolution expressly recognizes that Spokane is growing and that Vinegar Flats will be part of that growth.
But we were never given the basic parameters necessary to facilitate the next part of that conversation.
We could ask our neighbors what they value. We could ask what they want to protect. But we could not meaningfully ask them to work through tradeoffs or collaboratively develop solutions because we were never told what outcome the City is actually trying to achieve in Vinegar Flats.
From a facilitation standpoint, that is backwards.
Why Vinegar Flats is not interchangeable
The decisions being made through this process are not abstract lines on a map. They affect people's homes, businesses, farms, investments, transportation, neighborhood relationships, and

[Source PDF page 1537]

the ecological systems that define this valley.
Vinegar Flats is also not an interchangeable piece of undeveloped land. It is a contained valley with Latah Creek running through it, working agricultural land, habitat and a wildlife corridor, established homes and businesses, and limited transportation connections.
Broadly extending high-intensity designations into that interior creates a very real risk of long-term or irreversible impacts to the ecological systems, agricultural lands, and creek corridor that make this area unique.
Once agricultural land is urbanized, habitat is fragmented, development pressure reaches the creek corridor, or the physical structure of the valley is fundamentally altered, some of those impacts may be extremely difficult—or impossible—to reverse.
Our alternative
That is why our alternative begins with a different planning question:
How can Vinegar Flats meaningfully accommodate Spokane's growth while putting that growth where it makes the most sense and protecting the resources that cannot be replaced?
The attached proposal attempts to answer that question constructively. It:
concentrates growth along Inland Empire Way
creates predictable boundaries
provides substantial additional MIX and RH capacity
creates a purposeful park-serving node
protects more agricultural opportunity; and
establishes a deliberate reduction in intensity as development moves toward Latah Creek.
What I am asking Planning to do
I am not asking Planning to accept every hand-drawn boundary exactly as submitted. I am asking you to study this alternative seriously.
Please use City GIS to:
test the proposed corridor depths
calculate the resulting MIX, RH and AG acreage and development capacity, evaluate the targeted RH locations, and
compare this alternative directly with the August Draft and Reconfigured Option.
Those specific requests are detailed in the attachment.
And, critically, please provide us with the missing objective:
How much growth is Vinegar Flats actually being asked to accommodate, and how was that amount determined?

[Source PDF page 1538]

Give us that information and an opportunity to work with Planning around it.
Our neighbors have demonstrated that they are willing to do the work. What we are asking for is the information necessary to make that work meaningful.
Thank you for considering this alternative and for including it in the record for the PlanSpokane 2046 Future Land Use Map.
Eme Ray
Chair, Latah-Hangman Neighborhood Council
Submitted in my individual capacity as a Vinegar Flats resident/property owner

[Source PDF page 1539]

V I N E G A R F L AT S
Corridor-Focused Growth Alternative
Proposed alternative to the PlanSpokane 2046 Draft Future Land Use Map
2
3
4
3
1
3
Mixed Use (MIX) Residential High (RH) Agriculture (AG)
Concept map — preliminary boundaries; City GIS verification and refinement requested. Numbers refer to “How the map works.”
FOCUSED GROWTH. PROTECTED VALLEY. A CLEAR TRANSITION.
Concentrate Mixed Use along Inland Empire Way. Target Residential High where greater intensity is most appropriate. Maximize Agriculture toward Latah Creek.
Baseline August Draft Reconfigured Corridor Alternative*
MIX 8.5 ac 35.3 ac 39.7 ac ~28–30 ac
RH 0 ac 37.3 ac 37.3 ac ~9 ac
MIX + RH 8.5 ac 72.6 ac 77.0 ac ~37–39 ac
vs. baseline – 8.5× 9.1× ~4.4–4.6×
*Preliminary concept-level estimate; requested for verification by City GIS.
V I N E G A R F L AT S
C O R R I D O R - F O C U S E D G R O W T H A LT E R N AT I V E | O C TO B E R 2 , 2 0 2 6 | PA G E 1 O F 6

[Source PDF page 1540]

How the map works
The alternative uses Inland Empire Way as the organizing spine of the Urban Hub and establishes a deliberate transition in intensity toward the valley interior and Latah Creek.
1 MIX — Inland Empire Way corridor
Concentrate Mixed Use continuously along Inland Empire Way with a defined maximum depth rather than allowing unusually deep parcels to carry MIX into residential side streets. We ask Planning to test approximately 200, 250 and 300 feet to determine a viable development depth.
2 MIX — Wentel Grant Park / Parkside
Use full parcel depth in this specific area. The added depth can support parking, neighborhood- and park-serving businesses and services, gathering space, and complementary uses. A small amount of Residential High backs the MIX along the park, placing additional housing within easy reach of the park and its services. This is a purposeful exception tied to a public amenity, not a precedent for extending MIX down other side streets.
3 RH — targeted locations
Concentrate Residential High on selected sites already characterized by relatively concentrated residential use and sites particularly suited to redevelopment over the 20-year planning horizon, rather than creating a broad second band of higher intensity through the valley. This includes a small area backing the Wentel Grant Park/Parkside MIX node.
4 AG + creek — protect the valley edge
Outside the defined urban corridor and targeted RH sites, maximize Agriculture toward Latah Creek.
This preserves working agricultural opportunity and creates greater separation between the highest- intensity uses and the creek, tributaries, habitat and wildlife corridor.
INLAND EMPIRE WAY → MIX → RH / TRANSITION → AGRICULTURE / OPEN VALLEY →
LATAH CREEK
The organizing principle is simple: development intensity should generally decrease with distance from Inland Empire Way and proximity to Latah Creek.
Why this is a stronger planning alternative
It accepts substantial growth. The concept increases MIX/RH from 8.5 acres at baseline to an estimated 37–39 acres — more than four times today’s higher-intensity acreage. It is not a no-growth proposal.
It creates a legible urban corridor. Spokane’s Centers and Corridors framework is a focused-growth strategy: higher intensity is directed toward identifiable centers and transportation corridors. Inland Empire Way provides a clear organizing spine for that approach.
It creates predictable boundaries. Historic parcel depths vary substantially. A measurable corridor depth gives residents, property owners, developers and the City a comprehensible boundary instead of allowing intensity to reach farther into the valley simply because a parcel happens to be deep.
V I N E G A R F L AT S
C O R R I D O R - F O C U S E D G R O W T H A LT E R N AT I V E | O C TO B E R 2 , 2 0 2 6 | PA G E 2 O F 6

[Source PDF page 1541]

It uses extra depth where it serves a purpose. The Wentel Grant Park/Parkside exception allows additional depth where parking, services and gathering-oriented uses can support a neighborhood amenity, with a small amount of Residential High backing that node.
It protects the creek through land-use pattern, not only future mitigation. The FLUM itself can establish a transition away from higher-intensity designations before later zoning and development regulations are written.
It treats agriculture as an active long-term use. Spokane Municipal Code expressly recognizes agricultural activities as an important part of the character of the Latah Creek valley and states the City’s intent to protect agricultural activity there from pressures that could prematurely remove land from agricultural use.
The scale question remains unresolved
The City has not provided the neighborhood with a quantified housing-unit or population target for Vinegar Flats. Without that information, residents cannot determine what share of Spokane’s citywide growth need this redesignation is intended to accommodate, or whether approximately 73–77 acres of MIX/RH are necessary to achieve that objective.
The City’s 2025 Land Capacity Analysis identifies a need to accommodate almost 22,400 additional housing units through 2046 and concludes that Spokane, in general, has capacity to accommodate the projected population and housing need and exceed it. The corridor-focused alternative therefore asks the City to test whether its objectives can be met through a more concentrated pattern rather than assuming the broadest geographic expansion is necessary.
Direct alignment with the adopted LHNC resolution This concept is not presented as a map formally adopted by the Latah-Hangman Neighborhood Council, and it is not issued by the Council. It is a proposed physical implementation of principles the Council adopted on October 1, 2026.
GROWTH
“We recognize that Spokane is growing and that Vinegar Flats will be part of that growth. We want to work with the City to help shape how and where that growth occurs.”
W H AT S H O U L D G U I D E G R O W T H
“Future planning for Vinegar Flats should protect the qualities neighbors identified as most important, particularly Latah Creek and its natural environment, wildlife, working agriculture, open space, and the rural character of the valley.”
L O C AT I O N O F M I X E D U S E
“We support a neighborhood-serving Mixed Use area along Inland Empire Way while limiting its expansion into the valley interior, agricultural land, and the Latah Creek corridor.”
SCALE AND DISTRIBUTION
“We have concerns about the amount of future growth concentrated in Vinegar Flats under the proposed map and ask the City to explain how the scale and distribution of that growth were determined.”
V I N E G A R F L AT S
C O R R I D O R - F O C U S E D G R O W T H A LT E R N AT I V E | O C TO B E R 2 , 2 0 2 6 | PA G E 3 O F 6

[Source PDF page 1542]

The neighborhood process behind those principles
The resolution records approximately 90 written responses gathered at the September 24 planning meeting.
The strongest themes were nature and wildlife, farming, neighbors and community, rural and quiet character, safety and traffic, and Latah Creek.
The Planning Committee vote record also shows strong support for the underlying principles: Agriculture 28 agree / 1 can live with / 0 disagree; Latah Creek 29 / 0 / 0; Scale and Distribution 30 / 0 / 0; Scale and Transitions 27 / 0 / 0; Creek Protection 29 / 0 / 0; Infrastructure and Safety 30 / 0 / 0. The Location of
Mixed Use statement was supported with 14 agree, 8 can live with, and 8 disagree, underscoring the value of continued refinement and discussion of the exact boundary.
What we are asking Planning to do
Study and refine this alternative — not simply accept or reject a hand-drawn line.
Map and compare 200-, 250- and 300-foot MIX corridor depths along Inland Empire Way.
Allow full MIX parcel depth at Wentel Grant Park/Parkside, backed by a small area of Residential High, so the node can accommodate parking, services and park-supportive uses.
Evaluate targeted RH sites based on existing residential intensity, redevelopment suitability, infrastructure and compatibility rather than applying a broad RH band.
Maximize retention or expansion of AG toward Latah Creek consistent with existing agricultural uses, environmental constraints and natural-resource objectives.
Use City GIS to calculate MIX, RH and AG acreage for this concept and compare it directly with the August Draft and Reconfigured Option.
Provide the housing/population capacity assumptions being applied to Vinegar Flats so the neighborhood can understand the scale and distribution of proposed growth.
Continue working with Vinegar Flats residents, property owners and businesses to refine the boundary before the FLUM is finalized.
A balanced 20-year pattern
Vinegar Flats does not need to choose between growth and preservation. This concept accepts substantial change while asking that change be organized around the place best suited to carry it: Inland Empire Way.
It provides considerably more land for MIX and RH than exists today, creates a purposeful park-serving node, directs higher residential intensity selectively, preserves more agricultural opportunity, and establishes a clearer transition toward Latah Creek.
Accommodate Spokane’s future growth without unnecessarily sacrificing the qualities that make Vinegar Flats distinct.
V I N E G A R F L AT S
C O R R I D O R - F O C U S E D G R O W T H A LT E R N AT I V E | O C TO B E R 2 , 2 0 2 6 | PA G E 4 O F 6

[Source PDF page 1543]

City alternatives and supporting context
City-provided comparison graphic: Baseline Conversion, August Draft FLUM, and Reconfigured Option.
Sources
City of Spokane, 2025 Land Capacity Analysis — identifies almost 22,400 additional housing units needed through 2046 and concludes the City generally has capacity to meet and exceed projected population and housing needs.
City of Spokane, Centers and Corridors Study / historical growth strategy — describes Centers and Corridors as a focused-growth approach directing density and mixed-use development near retail, services, employment and transportation.
Spokane Municipal Code 17C.111.125 — recognizes agricultural activities as an important part of the character of the Latah Creek valley and states the City’s intent to protect agricultural activity from pressures that could prematurely remove land from agricultural use.
Latah-Hangman Neighborhood Council, Resolution of October 1, 2026 on the Draft Future Land Use Map for Vinegar
Flats.
V I N E G A R F L AT S
C O R R I D O R - F O C U S E D G R O W T H A LT E R N AT I V E | O C TO B E R 2 , 2 0 2 6 | PA G E 5 O F 6

[Source PDF page 1544]

Support for consideration of this alternative
The individuals below support City evaluation and refinement of the Vinegar Flats Corridor-Focused Growth Alternative. Signatures indicate support for consideration of this proposed implementation; they do not represent adoption of this exact map by the Latah-Hangman Neighborhood Council.
Name Address / Property / Business Signature Date
V I N E G A R F L AT S
C O R R I D O R - F O C U S E D G R O W T H A LT E R N AT I V E | O C TO B E R 2 , 2 0 2 6 | PA G E 6 O F 6